Equipment failure rates from public databases#

For the expanded solar-specific review, including trackers, weather stations and combiner boxes, see PV device reliability: 14 reviewed sources, 371 additional evidence records, new operational methods and three gallery examples.

Estimate failure rates from observed exposure, use documented industry distributions as priors, and evaluate fault-interval models. The implementation separates input connectors → numerical methods → applied analysis. It does not equate degradation, unavailability, incident counts, and failure rates.

Included databases and coverage#

The frozen releases below were retrieved on 7 November 2026. Publication vintage and observation dates are retained separately. These are historical benchmarks, not a claim to represent today’s equipment fleet.

Source

Stored / usable records

Equipment and scope

Access

NRC/INL 2020 update, Table 1

300 / 294

58 published equipment groups; all table rows, including legacy estimates

Public report; underlying IRIS records restricted

Sandia PVROM 2018, Appendix A

63 / 39

All published failure fits across 18 headings, including inverter fault groups and grid events

Public distributions; raw work orders not included

Carroll et al. 2016, Figure 3

76 / 76

19 offshore wind subassemblies × 4 repair categories

Public numerical table from approximately 350 European turbines

Backblaze 2013

40 / 40

Every drive model in the daily CSV archive

Public raw observations; attribution and no resale of source data

479 stored records; 449 evaluated records. These are source/population/mode records, not 479 distinct devices. Device categories overlap across sources. Snapshot JSON files ship in the retrieval wheel; the study exports Parquet, CSV, JSON and a four-panel figure. Downloaded PDFs/archives are not committed.

NRC coverage includes actuated/manual/check/relief valves; motor-, turbine-, engine- and positive-displacement pumps; diesel/hydro/combustion generators; battery chargers, batteries, transfer switches, breakers, inverters, buses, motor-control centres, transformers, sequencers and fuses; strainers and screens; sensors, logic, relays and switches; reactor-specific equipment; dampers, air handlers, chillers and fans; compressors, dryers, accumulators, cooling-tower fans, tanks, orifices, pipes and heat exchangers. Nuclear batteries/inverters are not automatically lithium-ion BESS/PV equivalents; nuclear backup hydro generators are not a global hydro fleet.

PV coverage includes modules, combiners, inverters, fans, IGBTs, cooling, power cycling, fuse/hardware faults, ground/arc faults, AC disconnects, transformers, grid/recloser events, data acquisition, PLCs and hydraulic cylinders. Preventive maintenance remains in the audit but is excluded from failure calculations.

Wind coverage includes pitch/hydraulics, generators, gearboxes, blades, lubrication, electrical components, contactors/breakers/relays, controls, safety, sensors, pumps/motors, hubs, heating/cooling, yaw, towers/foundations, converters/power supplies, service items and other components. No underlying OEM identities are inferred from the anonymized fleet.

Run the analysis#

uv sync --locked --all-packages
uv run python -m energy_analysis.failure_reliability --output artifacts/failure-reliability

Outputs include failure_database.parquet, failure_database.json, failure_estimates.csv, wind_budget_scenario.csv, sources.json, summary.json and failure_reliability.png. The gallery runs offline:

from energy_data_retrieval.failure_database import load_failure_database, source_catalogue

database = load_failure_database()  # excludes quarantined records
audit = load_failure_database(include_flagged=True)
pumps = database[database.device.str.contains("Pump", case=False)]
print(pumps[["device", "failure_mode", "basis", "distribution", "source_url"]])
print(source_catalogue()[["source_id", "access", "limitations"]])

Explicit live refresh, with byte limits and source SHA-256 verification:

uv sync --locked --all-packages --extra reliability
uv run python scripts/refresh_failure_database.py nrc_2020 --output artifacts/refreshed
uv run python scripts/refresh_failure_database.py pvrom_2018 --output artifacts/refreshed
uv run python scripts/refresh_failure_database.py wind_2016 --output artifacts/refreshed
uv run python scripts/refresh_failure_database.py backblaze_2013 --output artifacts/refreshed

These reproduce specific releases. An upstream document change fails the hash check and requires review; it does not silently replace the benchmark. The optional PDF parser uses pdfplumber; ordinary snapshot use needs no PDF dependency. Backblaze’s 2013 archive is approximately 78 MiB compressed; expanded content is bounded to 1 GB and read one daily CSV at a time, without filesystem extraction. aggregate_backblaze also accepts current daily CSVs downloaded separately from the provider. The connector does not automatically download multi-GB quarters.

Methods and units#

Input

Estimator/model

Output

Failure count \(k\), summed at-risk time \(T\)

\(\hat\lambda=k/T\); exact central Poisson count interval

Failures per declared time unit; constant-rate MTBF \(1/\lambda\)

Zero failures over \(T\)

One-sided bound \(-\ln(1-c)/T\)

Upper rate bound at confidence \(c\); zero observed failures does not prove zero risk

Gamma industry prior \((a,b)\), new failures/exposure

Shape/rate posterior \((a+k,b+T)\)

Mean rate and credible interval; predictive \(1-(b/(b+t))^a\)

Beta prior \((a,b)\), new failures \(k\) in \(n\) demands

\((a+k,b+n-k)\)

Per-demand probability and beta-binomial predictive probability

Lifetimes plus survivor censoring flags

Weibull maximum likelihood, including censored survival terms

Shape and scale; conditional future-event probability

Published lifetime/fault-interval fit

\(1-S(a+h)/S(a)\)

Probability of the next event over horizon \(h\) conditional on event-free age \(a\)

The count estimator and zero-failure bounds follow the NIST engineering statistics handbook. Poisson intervals assume independent homogeneous fixed-exposure counts; they do not account for reporting bias, repeated-failure dependence or fleet heterogeneity. NRC’s industry-distribution percentiles are a different uncertainty quantity.

Gamma rate uncertainty uses a rate parameter with units of exposure. Gamma lifetime uses a time scale. Weibull scale has the same time unit as age. Pipe records remain per foot-hour; demand records remain per demand. No conversion to annual probability is made without an explicit exposure/demand mission.

from energy_methods.failure_rates import estimate_rate, GammaRate, BetaDemand

observed = estimate_rate(failures=2, exposure=800)  # device-hours
print(observed.rate, observed.lower, observed.upper)

# Synthetic illustration: local data must be independent of the industry prior.
prior = GammaRate(shape=2, rate=100_000)
posterior = prior.update(failures=3, exposure=50_000)
print(posterior.probability_at_least_one(8760))

start_failure = BetaDemand(alpha=1, beta=999).update(failures=1, demands=500)
print(start_failure.probability_at_least_one(demands=12))

For any device absent from the supplied sources, use your own event count and summed exposure in estimate_rate, or include all survivors in fit_weibull_censored(times, failed). Times must start at device age zero: the first SCADA observation is not necessarily the installation date. The fitter does not support delayed entry, recurrent-event intervals or interval censoring. Do not pool populations without matching duty, environment, maintenance, failure definitions and observation windows. Do not update a prior with the same observations used to construct it. The package deliberately has no automatic cross-technology transfer or pooling function.

Results and interpretation#

The NRC normally-running motor-driven pump example reports a mean of 2.26 failures per million run-hours, with source 5th/95th percentiles of 0.394 and 5.38. This is a nuclear fleet benchmark for the specified failure mode; it is not a calibrated estimate for a solar-plant pump.

The wind table sums to 8.273 repair events per turbine-year (the paper’s prose rounds the fleet value to 8.3). Pitch/hydraulics has the highest subsystem event frequency, 1.076 per turbine-year. Major gearbox replacements occur at 0.154 per turbine-year in this historical sample. Under the explicitly illustrative costs below, gearboxes and generators dominate direct repair cost, despite pitch/hydraulics having more events.

Illustrative input

Value

Fleet

100 turbines

Minor repair

EUR 500/event

Major repair

EUR 5,000/event

Major replacement

EUR 50,000/event

Unknown-cost event

EUR 1,500/event

Expected events/year

827.3

Expected direct repair cost/year

EUR 2,280,100

This is a sensitivity case, not a current price quote or a complete O&M budget. It excludes lost generation, vessel/access constraints, logistics and correlations. Replace costs through wind_maintenance_budget(cost_per_event=...).

The complete 2013 Backblaze archive yields 724 reported failures over 5,091,501 observed drive-days, across 40 models. Calendar gaps add no exposure. There are 180 observed drive-days after a prior reported failure and zero repeated failure flags; these audit fields remain visible. Results describe recorded events and are not independent first-failure lifetime data. Tiny model cohorts and zero-event cohorts retain their uncertainty; historical model comparisons are not purchasing recommendations. Drive model strings alone are not used to infer SSD/HDD technology for arbitrary future imports.

PVROM curves describe the source’s portfolio-specific fault/failure intervals, including resets and grid-related events. They cannot establish universal warranty life or a 30-50-year replacement plan. Plotted five-year curves are extrapolations of historical fitted distributions, with no invented parameter confidence bands. Normal time models are explicitly conditioned on nonnegative time; this is an implementation adaptation, not an exact reproduction of an untruncated fit.

Data-quality exclusions and access gaps#

  • Six NRC rows have a distribution/unit conflict: MDP-FTS-CCW, CTG-FTLR, CRD-FTOP, ROD-FTOP, MOD-ILS, EDC-FTR-NR. The connector preserves the published values and excludes them from forecasts pending source review.

  • PVROM: 19 duplicate year-based fits are excluded in favour of the source’s day/hour rows; two preventive-maintenance fits are not failures; three Lognormal rows have ambiguous mean/standard-deviation conventions. Explicit Lognormal-n uses the underlying normal parameters as documented.

  • The PVROM 2020 Table 3-1 summary is catalogued but not numerically ingested: reported means and scale conventions need clarification, and the statistic concerns first occurrence at system level rather than identifiable devices.

  • OREDA@Cloud requires subscription/member access. No public numeric endpoint or licensed export was available for this contribution.

  • EPRI’s BESS incident database is an incident source. Without a matched at-risk fleet denominator and reporting completeness, its counts do not determine a component failure rate. Battery degradation/cycling datasets likewise do not establish fleet failure incidence.

  • Sandia CREW publishes benchmarks but its underlying operating data are restricted.

Sources retain their own terms. The repository’s software license does not relicense third-party publications or datasets. Backblaze attribution and its restriction on selling the source data itself apply to its extract.